23
Sep

What Makes a Historical Novel Great?

   Posted by: GG Vandagriff   in Essays

[I had to write an article for a magazine for my SEO tasks, and this is what happened.  Thought I would share it with you, after adding the last two paragraphs]

I grew up on a diet of historical novels, mostly the romantic with a small r kind. However, when I graduated to the classics, I knew I had found my real genre. "I was born in the wrong era," I thought.

And then, I became a writer, and I entered an historical era of my dreams, tip-toeing softly, gathering atmosphere, facts, foods, language—a zeigeist entirely different from my own pedestrian existence. And, still I didn’t get it right. It wasn’t until I studied why those classic novels were great that I could dare to presume to publish The Last Waltz.

Tolstoy, Hugo, Dostoevsky, Gaskill, Bronte, Austen—what made them so great that they still continue to be relevant, dramatized, and studied? I truly believe the answer is that they wrote of redemption of character. The authors believed in a universe where the hard questions of life had answers. They believed in right and wrong.

Margaret Hale, of Gaskill’s North and South, is my favorite heroine. Up against the hard questions posed by the English Industrial Revolution—class barriers, poverty, and greed—she managed to redeem all those in her small circle of existence with her love and her righteous principles. Her influence traveled beyond her circle and redeemed strategic characters in an industrial town in Victorian England. This was not a fairy tale. It was very real, because it depicted love as it really is—a devotion that acknowledges flaws, but works past them, appealing to the innate goodness of man. Elizabeth Gaskill believed in innate goodness, as did Tolstoy, Hugo, Bronte, etc.

Why is it that the current young generation is turning to fantasy literature in overwhelming numbers? Because fantasy worlds are built on the existence of good and evil. Until this age of relativism, that was the nature of art. And deep within, we still know this.

World renowned critic, John Gardner, explains this far more eloquently than I, in speaking of my favorite author and his work. "Leo Tolstoy knew about the universe of despair and endured a perhaps similar spiritual crisis [to that of Sartre], a crisis certainly profound and all-transforming. He came out of it not with a theory that every man should make up his own rules, asserting values for all men for all time, but with a theory of submission, a theory which equally emphasized freedom but argued that what a man ought to do with his freedom is be quiet, look and listen, try to feel out in his heart and bones what God requires of him—as Levin does in Anna Karenina, or Pierre in War and Peace."(Gardner, John, On Moral Fiction, Basic Books, Inc.: New York, p. 25)

Gardner further asserts that great art always builds, seeking to improve life, not debase it.

Why was Les Miserables one of the greatest stage productions of the modern era? Because it was heroic. It made us believe and embrace the idea that man could change, could be redeemed, could love enough to want to sacrifice, even in a time of great blackness and despair. Though the mid-nineteenth century French revolution failed, Valjean was victorious in his heart and soul.

So when I wanted to write a novel about the triumph of the soul in dark times, I took a lesson from the Greats. I set it in the past, where it would not be unfashionable. Is it too late for us? Genre fiction still deals with good and evil. Should not literary fiction take a lesson from the popularity of such books, possibly even finding a mission there?

Certainly, we as LDS authors and readers should. Remember the Orson F. Whitney prophesy: "We shall yet have Miltons and Shakespeares of our own. God’s ammunition is not exhausted. His highest spirits are held in reserve for the latter times. In God’s name and by His help we will build up a literature whose tops will touch the heaven, though its foundation may now be low on the earth." ("The Arts and the Spirit of the Lord," Boyd K. Packer, Ensign, 1976.)

Inspired by this quote, the LDStorymakers have instituted the Whitney Awards for excellence in fiction. Why not support those LDS writers most in keeping with this revelation by going to http://www.whitneyawards.com and nominating your favorite books?

Share
This entry was posted on Wednesday, September 23rd, 2009 at 6:57 am and is filed under Essays. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

5 comments so far

 1 

I’m applauding, GG. The “power of one” theme is among my favorites, and characters who embody the determination to rise above the odds abound in real history, and hopefully will continue to appear in the work we each create. The world will always need heroes and champions, rooted in goodness, drawing a line in the moral/ethical sand.

September 24th, 2009 at 8:25 am
 2 

Interesting. I agree that a sense of the heroic and clear moral definition strengthen any story, but don’t you think the intrigue of history is what makes historical fiction so powerful? I think when you can find a story that mirrors the evolving world events around it, both the character’s growth and history itself become more pronounced and meaningful. For Tolstoy, Les Miserables and most of Austen’s books, it was the juxtaposition of the history to the story that worked. That’s why I’m not a big regency fan (any plot as long as she’s wearing a corset.) There has to be a reason it is set in that time.

September 24th, 2009 at 10:42 am
 3 

Thanks, Laurie. I just hope in my “history” I will make the right decisions. That’s the power of the historical novel, I think. It gives us a sense of proportion.

September 24th, 2009 at 11:03 am
Michele Ashman Bell
 4 

Such a profound and “over my head” post. I have to print it off and digest it in small bits so I can really absorb your wisdom and insight. I am in awe of you and appreciate you sharing your great passion for historical fiction and writing. You are such a great inspiration to me. Bon voyage!

September 26th, 2009 at 8:11 pm
 5 

Thank you for such an inspiring post. The stories that linger with us after we finish the book, stay in our heads for days as we retrace the choices, the actions the heroes and heroines made… those are the stories I love to read… and the stories I am trying to write.
But the historical novel offers an escape… when done well, an almost tactile classroom I love to attend.
The Last Waltz is next on my reading list!

September 27th, 2009 at 7:06 pm

Leave a reply

Name (*)
Mail (will not be published) (*)
URI
Comment